Open question 5 of 16From Chapter 1: The shot1-minute readCourt record

Who falsely claimed to be the shooter?

Within minutes a man at the scene told a detective he did it. Police say he was not the shooter. What the record shows.

The short version

According to charging documents, George Zinn, 71, told a UVU police detective 'I shot him, now shoot me' about two minutes after the shot; he was handcuffed about 12:25 pm, no gun was found, and he was taken to the UVU Police Department. Investigators later said he did not shoot Kirk;

This is the official account. The defendant is presumed innocent.

Sources (9)

Where the accounts differ (2)

Police booking affidavit (as reported by KSL, the Salt Lake Tribune and The Guardian) Reported

At the hospital later that day, Zinn told an officer he 'was glad he said he shot the individual so the real suspect could get away'. The sheriff's office said it had no information that he colluded with the shooter.

Sources (4)

Texts attributed to the defendant (affidavit) Reported

'they grabbed some crazy old dude, then interrogated someone in similar clothing'.

Sources (1)

What remains open

How many officers did the false confession tie up, and for how long, in the minutes the shooter was leaving the roof?

Related questions

False-suspect custody report and the first campus alert

Official record

After-action report timeline: 12:26 UVUPD reports a suspect (an attendee) in custody after he allegedly admitted involvement; later determined not a suspect. The first campus alert at 12:42 said a suspect was in custody, corrected about 20 minutes later.

Sources (1)
Where accounts differ (1)

Press reporting Reported

The man who shouted 'I shot him' was detained by a UVU detective and walked to UVU PD about two minutes after the shot.

Sources (2)

What remains open

How long did the false-suspect report shape the first campus alerts and outside agency messaging?

'Subject in custody' (10 Sep)

Official record

FBI Director Kash Patel posted at 16:21 MDT that 'the subject ... is now in custody', then at 17:59 MDT that the person 'has been released after an interrogation'. He later said he didn't regret the posts.

Sources (3)
Where accounts differ (1)

Utah officials (same evening, via CBS) Reported

The shooter was still at large.

Sources (1)

What remains open

What is known about the person released, and whether the 12:42 UVU alert and FBI post relied on the same information?

Court documents on this: Search warrant No. 3213501 and affidavit · Search warrant No. 3215171 and affidavit · State v. George Zinn · Independent External Review / After-Action Report on t

← Back in the story: Chapter 1, The shot