Open question 2 of 16From Chapter 1: The shot1-minute readDisputed

Who was responsible for the rooftops?

The university’s review sets out where officers were posted that day. What it says about the roofs, and what it does not cover.

The short version

The after-action report: TPUSA security and UVUPD both failed to make sure a joint briefing and walk-through happened. No line-of-sight or rooftop plan existed. Barriers and cameras were added to the Losee roof afterwards.

This is the official account. The defendant is presumed innocent.

Sources (2)

Where the accounts differ (2)

Andrew Kolvet, TPUSA spokesperson (24 Sep 2025; 15 Dec 2025; 16 Sep 2026) Commentary · claim

Andrew Kolvet, TPUSA spokesperson (24 Sep 2025; 15 Dec 2025; 16 Sep 2026) claims: TPUSA's security had 'jurisdiction' only around Charlie. 'UVU Campus PD was in charge of perimeter.' The rooftop was a known student hangout.

Sources (3)

Executive-protection commentator (MSB Protection) Commentary · claim

Executive-protection commentator (MSB Protection) claims: Private security has no 'jurisdiction' anywhere. The duty is to advise the principal on risks.

Sources (1)

What remains open

What do records show about assignments to elevated positions and the planned 11:00 walkway meeting?

Related questions

Elevated positions that were covered

Official record

UVUPD cleared and taped off the Hall of Flags walkway above the canopy at TPUSA's security supervisor's request, and posted two officers there. The report found no documented review of other elevated positions, including the Losee Center roof.

Sources (1)
Where accounts differ (1)

Security lead Brian Harpole (own account) Claimed

'Federal law' would not allow his team to post a counter-sniper on a roof.

Sources (2)

What remains open

How did security assignments differ between the elevated walkway and the nearby Losee Center roof?

Police staffing at the event

Disputed

Testimony and the after-action report: UVUPD fielded six sworn officers for about 3,000 people. Staffing began with the chief, one patrol officer and one reserve, and more were requested after the crowd grew. No Utah County deputies were there.

Sources (2)
Where accounts differ (2)

Security lead's own account (Shawn Ryan Show) Claimed

Kirk's personal detail was the security lead, the security supervisor, a driver and one more team member.

Sources (1)

Kirk family notice of claim (as reported) Disputed

Cites '25% of force'.

Sources (1)

What remains open

Was six officers in line with UVU's own major-event policy for an expected 600, then actual 3,000, attendance?

Court documents on this: Independent External Review / After-Action Report on t · Notice of Claim against the State of Utah

← Back in the story: Chapter 1, The shot