Open question 4 of 16From Chapter 1: The shot1-minute readDisputed
Who chose the courtyard?
Three thousand people gathered in one courtyard. How the review and others describe the choice of venue.
The short version
The after-action report: TPUSA's initial email of 10 Jul 2025 asked for the Fountain Courtyard. UVU raised concerns at the 25 Aug committee meeting but agreed when TPUSA's field representative insisted.
This is the official account. The defendant is presumed innocent.
Sources (1)
- UVU Independent External Review, After-Action ReportOfficial · 2026-09-25
Where the accounts differ (1)
Security lead Brian Harpole (own account) Disputed
Attributed claim: The venue was chosen by UVU, which told TPUSA 'this is where you have to have it'.
Sources (2)
- Shawn Ryan Show interview with Brian Harpole, 17 Nov 2025 (channel)Party statement · 2025-11-17
- UVU Independent External Review, After-Action ReportOfficial · 2026-09-25
What remains open
What do the 10 July email and committee minutes say about the venue choice, if released?
Related questions
Choice of the outdoor courtyard
Disputed
The after-action report says UVU staff raised concerns at the 25 Aug Major Events Assessment Committee and suggested alternatives. TPUSA insisted on the Fountain Courtyard, citing Kirk's 2019 visit. The event was approved on 27 Aug before any security assessment.
Sources (1)
- UVU Independent External Review, After-Action ReportOfficial · 2026-09-25
Where accounts differ (1)
Security lead Brian Harpole (own account, Shawn Ryan Show) Claimed
Attributed claim: He was concerned about the open-air venue and sightlines, but was told it 'needed to be held in that location'.
Sources (1)
- Shawn Ryan Show interview with Brian Harpole, 17 Nov 2025 (channel)Party statement · 2025-11-17
What remains open
What do records show about the choice to keep the venue outdoors and the security lead's concerns?
Independent review's 'bad faith' finding vs the family's claim
Disputed
The review found no UVU employee or agent acted in bad faith or with 'willful and wanton disregard'. It made 147 recommendations.
Sources (2)
- UVU Independent External Review, After-Action ReportOfficial · 2026-09-25
- Axios Salt Lake City, 'UVU audit reveals security gaps at Charlie Kirk event', 25 Sep 2026News report · 2026-09-25
Where accounts differ (1)
Kirk family (notice of claim, 16 Sep 2026) Disputed
Security failures by the State, UVU, UVUPD, the chief and the former president made the death preventable.
Sources (2)
- KSL, 'Kirk family puts UVU on notice it intends to sue'News report · 2026-09-16
- UVU Review, 'Kirk Family Files Notice of Claim Against UVU Over Security Failures'mainstream (student) · 2026-09
What remains open
Utah's immunity law may turn on a 'willful and wanton' standard (see the Gabby Petito appeal). Will a court test the review's finding?
Court documents on this: Independent External Review / After-Action Report on t · Notice of Claim against the State of Utah