Open question 9 of 16From Chapter 3: The accused1-minute readDisputed

When did he arrive at the sheriff’s office?

He walked in with his parents. The sworn affidavit and the sheriff’s account give different times.

The short version

SBI Investigator Justin Bowen's sworn warrant affidavits say the defendant 'arrived at the Washington County Sheriff's Office accompanied by his parents at approximately 2226 hours'.

This is the official account. The defendant is presumed innocent.

Sources (2)

Where the accounts differ (2)

Washington County Sheriff Nate Brooksby (public statements, via KUTV and Fox News) Reported

He got the tip call at about 8:02 p.m., and the defendant was brought in 'within the hour'. He then waited about 2½ hours for investigators from Orem.

Sources (2)

SBI case agent Brian Davis (prelim testimony, 8 Jul 2026; hearsay, 'I was told') Reported

Arrival around 21:00.

Sources (1)

What remains open

Did the defendant arrive at about 21:00 or at about 22:26? Two official accounts differ by roughly an hour and a half.

Related questions

Date of the surrender

Disputed

Court records, the FBI and wire reporting put the surrender and custody on the evening of 11 Sep 2025, with booking on 12 Sep.

Sources (3)
Where accounts differ (1)

UVU after-action report Disputed

Dates the surrender to 12 Sep 2025.

Sources (1)

What remains open

How does the university's official review date compare with the court record?

Booking / arrest time on 12 Sep

Disputed

The booking probable-cause statement records the arrest as 12 Sep 2025 04:00 and 'Probable Cause Entered 07:18'. The sheriff said he was driven to Utah County at about 02:00.

Sources (2)
Where accounts differ (1)

ABC4 reporting Disputed

Booking at 8:40 a.m.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

What remains open

What do the records say about the reported booking time and what each timestamp records?

How the surrender was arranged

Disputed

Affidavit: Utah County Sheriff Smith got a call at about 20:04 from Washington County Sheriff Brooksby, who had heard from a former sheriff's deputy who knew the family. The defendant had confessed to his father. Brooksby (KUTV): a 'retired detective' friend called him at about 8:02 p.m.

Sources (2)
Where accounts differ (1)

CBS News, citing law-enforcement sources Disputed

His father called a youth pastor, a court security officer, who also called the US Marshals Service.

Sources (1)

What remains open

Was the intermediary one person or two, and did the US Marshals have a role before the sheriff's office?

Court documents on this: Search warrant No. 3213501 and affidavit · Search warrant No. 3213811 and affidavit · Affidavit of Probable Cause · Independent External Review / After-Action Report on t

← Back in the story: Chapter 3, The accused