IllustrationIllustration: an abstract valley at night with no recognisable landmarks.
Illustration, generated for this archive. Not a real location and not evidence.

Chapter 3 of 6 · Thursday 11 to Tuesday 16 September 2025

The accused

A sheriff’s office, a name and seven counts.

At about 8:04 p.m. on Thursday, Utah County Sheriff Smith takes a call from Washington County Sheriff Brooksby. Brooksby has heard from a former sheriff’s deputy who knows the family, the affidavit says. The defendant, the affidavit says, has confessed to his father.12

According to a sworn affidavit, Tyler Robinson, 22, arrives at the Washington County Sheriff’s Office with his parents at about 10:26 p.m. He is arrested.314 Open question

His former roommate shows the FBI a set of texts at about 1:00 a.m. on 12 September. Quoted in the affidavits and the charging documents, they become part of the case. The State later says the roommate received use immunity for recorded statements.156 Open question

On 16 September, prosecutors file seven counts, aggravated murder among them, and say they will seek the death penalty.5

Robinson is presumed innocent, and nothing filed so far has been tried before a jury. He is one defendant, charged alone.5 Open question

The State’s case now has to be shown. The next chapter sets out what it says it has.

Sources for this chapter 6
  1. Court record Warrant affidavit No. 3213501 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
  2. News report KUTV, 'Washington Co. sheriff details how tip from retired detective brought in Tyler Robinson
  3. Court record Warrant affidavit No. 3213811 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
  4. News report Deseret News: the arrest, 12 Sep 2025
  5. Court record Utah County Attorney: charging information, 16 Sep 2025 (PDF)
  6. News report CBS News/AP: roommate given use immunity for recorded statements
Continue · Chapter 4 of 6The evidenceThe State’s case now has to be shown.