Open question 12 of 16From Chapter 4: The evidence1-minute readDisputed
What does the DNA evidence show?
The charging papers and the preliminary hearing describe DNA results. The full lab report has not been made public.
The short version
The charging Information's probable-cause statement alleges DNA consistent with the defendant on the trigger, other rifle parts, a fired casing, unfired cartridges and the towel. The FBI's 15 Sep 2025 public announcement named the towel and the screwdriver.
This is the official account. The defendant is presumed innocent.
Sources (2)
- Charging Information, State v. Robinson, Case 251403576 (Utah County Attorney)Court record · 2025-09-16
- Kirk Archive dataset
Where the accounts differ (1)
Preliminary hearing testimony (FBI and SBI analysts) Disputed
Public testimony focused on a mixed DNA profile on the towel ('very likely' the defendant, plus the roommate). Trigger DNA was not described in reported testimony.
Sources (1)
- Kirk Archive dataset
What remains open
Will the trigger DNA claimed in the charging document be backed by a lab report at trial?
Court documents on this: Information