IllustrationIllustration: a bare table with blank folders.
Illustration, generated for this archive. Not a real location and not evidence.

Chapter 4 of 6 · The case as filed

The evidence

A rifle, a towel, a trail of messages and a bullet.

The rifle is a Mauser Model 98 in .30-06, bolt-action, with a scope. It was wrapped in a dark towel, and the casings are engraved. Texts quoted in the affidavits call it “grandpa’s rifle”.123

The charging document alleges the defendant’s DNA is on the trigger, other rifle parts, a fired casing, unfired cartridges and the towel.3 FBI DNA analyst Amanda Bakker later testifies about the DNA findings from the towel.4 Open question

Then there is the bullet. A federal firearms examiner, Samantha Karner of the ATF, testifies that her toolmark comparison of the fatal fragment was inconclusive: it neither matched nor excluded the rifle. She received four of the seven recovered fragments. The State plans further testing, metallurgy and virtual comparison microscopy.56 Open question

When investigators search the Challenger they seize a Vantrue dash camera. Its power cord is disconnected and lying on the front passenger seat. It goes to the Regional Computer Forensic Laboratory.7 Open question

The file also holds video: university cameras, the neighbour’s doorbell camera and the car-wash footage. State investigator David Hull testifies about the surveillance footage and about the defendant’s movements on campus. The lead investigator testifies that the defendant was on campus about four times that day, twice before the shooting.89

As filed, the State’s case rests on DNA, a rifle, messages and video. A judge is about to hear it tested.

Sources for this chapter 9
  1. Court record Warrant affidavit No. 3212941 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
  2. Court record Warrant affidavit No. 3214291 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
  3. Court record Utah County Attorney: charging information, 16 Sep 2025 (PDF)
  4. News report PBS NewsHour: DNA evidence at the preliminary hearing
  5. News report PBS NewsHour: what an inconclusive bullet analysis means
  6. News report KSL: next hearing on bullet-evidence testing
  7. Court record Warrant affidavit No. 3215391 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
  8. News report Associated Press: testimony of Investigator David Hull
  9. Court record Warrant affidavit No. 3213501 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
Continue · Chapter 5 of 6The courtroomA judge is about to hear it tested.