Open question 14 of 16From Chapter 3: The accused1-minute readDisputed
What do the text messages show?
The texts are quoted in the court papers. Their full metadata is not.
The short version
Affidavits and charging documents quote the defendant's texts to the roommate ('stuck in orem', 'grab my rifle', 'I am, I'm sorry', 'a bit over a week'). The roommate showed the texts to the FBI at about 01:00 on 12 Sep.
This is the official account. The defendant is presumed innocent.
Sources (2)
- Search warrant / affidavit No. 3213501: Warrant to seize and search the 2013 Dodge…Court record · 2025-09-12 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
- Charging Information, State v. Robinson, Case 251403576 (Utah County Attorney)Court record · 2025-09-16
Where the accounts differ (2)
Candace Owens channel Commentary · claim
Candace Owens channel claims: The 'my dad wants photos of the rifle' text can't predate about 09:21 on 11 Sep. Defence counsel read a 17:55 timestamp from Exhibit 16.1. Texts placed after 16:55 must predate 18:36.
Sources (2)
- Candace Owens channel, 12 Nov 2026 episode (guest host Baron Coleman), Ring-camera…Commentary · 2026-11-12
- Kirk Archive dataset
Commentators (Owens, Bannon and others) Commentary · claim
Commentators (Owens, Bannon and others) claims: Question the authenticity of the roommate's recorded interview.
Sources (1)
- Kirk Archive dataset
What remains open
Will full message metadata (send times, devices) be produced at trial so the sequence can be checked against the Ring timeline?
Related questions
Google Maps routes on the defendant's phone
Court record
Affidavits record a route at 12:46 MDT on 10 Sep (shopping complex to the Orem car wash) and one at 01:33 MDT on 11 Sep (near UVU to the St. George apartment).
Sources (3)
- Search warrant / affidavit No. 3215261: Warrant affidavit citing Google Maps routes…Court record · 2025-09-15 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
- Search warrant / affidavit No. 3215391: Warrant for the Challenger's dash camera; LPR…Court record · 2025-09-15 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
- Search warrant / affidavit No. 3216271: Warrant affidavit: Quick Quack car wash 12:57;…Court record · 2025-09-17 Unofficial copy, posted online by attorney Andrea Burkhart
Where accounts differ (1)
Candace Owens channel Commentary · claim
Candace Owens channel claims: Cites the 01:33 route from near the rifle site to St. George.
Sources (1)
- Candace Owens channel, 12 Nov 2026 episode (guest host Baron Coleman), Ring-camera…Commentary · 2026-11-12
What remains open
A route start time records when navigation began, not necessarily when he set off. Do the phone's location points confirm the drive?
Court documents on this: Information · Search warrant No. 3213501 and affidavit · Search warrant No. 3215261 and affidavit · Search warrant No. 3215391 and affidavit · Search warrant No. 3216271 and affidavit