Case compendium

Lawsuits & enquiries

Every court matter, claim, records appeal and formal review connected to the case that the archive has found, with its current status and the date it was last checked.

2 criminal cases

2 court orders

1 lawsuit

1 notice of claim

3 records appeals

1 independent review

3 legislatives

1 institutional change

  1. Criminal case

    State of Utah v. George Zinn (false claim to be the shooter)

    Court or body
    Fourth District Court, Provo (Judge Thomas Low)
    Case no.
    see sources
    Filed
    19 Sep 2025
    Brought by
    State of Utah (Utah County Attorney)
    Against
    George Zinn

    Status (checked 14 Nov 2026) Closed by plea, 29 Jan 2026: no contest to a reduced third-degree obstruction charge, sentenced 0-5 years in prison. In the same hearing he pleaded guilty to two counts of sexual exploitation of a minor in a separate case that arose from the search of his phone (two other counts dropped), sentenced to two terms of 1-15 years. All terms run concurrently; the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole sets the time served. No later parole decision found in mainstream reporting as of 14 Nov 2026.

    Charged with second-degree obstruction of justice after, according to charging documents, he told a UVU detective 'I shot him, now shoot me' about two minutes after the shot. Prosecutors said his statements diverted officers from securing the scene and finding the shooter.

    Bears on how police attention was diverted in the first minutes after the shot, and on the early 'suspect in custody' alerts.

    Sources (8)
  2. Notice of claim

    Kirk family notice of claim (intent to sue) v. State of Utah / UVU

    Court or body
    Utah Governmental Immunity Act pre-suit notice
    Case no.
    n/a
    Filed
    16 Sep 2026
    Brought by
    Estate of Charlie Kirk and heirs (incl. Erika Kirk); his parents as prospective plaintiffs
    Against
    State of Utah, Utah Valley University, UVU Police Department, UVU Police Chief Jeffrey Long, Former UVU President Astrid Tuminez

    Status (checked 13 Nov 2026) Notice dated 9 Sep 2026, announced 16 Sep. No lawsuit reported as of 13 Nov 2026. KSL: suits typically follow about 90 days after notice. UVU: 'aware of the notice'. Settlements over $2M need legislative approval (FOX 13).

    Alleges negligence: only six officers, no meaningful risk assessment or written security plan, no metal detectors or drones. Also alleges, on information and belief, that the chief's request for more officers was denied. These are allegations, not findings.

    The first formal civil step over UVU security. Outcome may depend on the 'willful and wanton' standard (Petito appeal).

    Sources (8)
  3. Lawsuit

    A related defamation suit

    Court or body
    US District Court, Middle District of Tennessee
    Case no.
    3:26-cv-00556
    Filed
    30 Apr 2026
    Brought by
    Brian Harpole

    Status (checked 10 Nov 2026) Pending; see Open Questions for the filing and its status.

    The head of Kirk’s security firm brought a related defamation suit. The allegations are the plaintiff’s and remain untested in court.

    See Open Questions for the attributed filing context.

    Sources (0)

    No public source listed.

  4. Criminal case

    State of Utah v. Tyler Robinson

    Court or body
    Fourth District Court, Utah County (Judge Tony Graf)
    Case no.
    251403576
    Filed
    16 Sep 2025
    Brought by
    State of Utah (Utah County Attorney)
    Against
    Tyler Robinson

    Status (checked 9 Nov 2026) Bound over on all seven counts (1 Sep 2026). Bullet-testing hearing 14 Jan 2027. Jury selection set for 21 Jun 2028.

    Aggravated murder and related counts. The defendant is presumed innocent.

    The main case. Its record is the 'formal account'.

    Sources (4)
  5. Court order

    Discovery status order (scale of discovery)

    Court or body
    Fourth District Court
    Case no.
    251403576
    Filed
    9 Nov 2026
    Brought by
    Court

    Status (checked 9 Nov 2026) Order entered

    Recites 49 productions, 30,983 files, ~3.3 TB, ~8 million artefacts.

    Compare with the defence's figures (CC-09).

    Sources (2)
    • Kirk Archive dataset
    • Kirk Archive dataset
  6. Independent review

    UVU Independent External Review: After-Action Report

    Court or body
    Independent external reviewer
    Case no.
    n/a
    Filed
    25 Sep 2026
    Brought by
    Utah Valley University (commissioned)

    Status (checked 25 Sep 2026) Published. 147 recommendations. No bad faith or 'willful and wanton disregard' found.

    Review of event planning, security and response.

    Main official source for campus-security items (CS-01 to CS-09).

    Sources (2)
  7. Records appeal

    Marshall (Judicial Watch) v. Utah Valley University

    Court or body
    Utah Government Records Office
    Case no.
    Decision 2026-004
    Filed
    2025
    Brought by
    Judicial Watch
    Against
    Utah Valley University

    Status (checked 10 Jul 2026) Decided 30 Mar 2026. Productions released Jul 2026 (clean-up and paving records).

    GRAMA request for UVU records.

    Source of the courtyard clean-up records (AE-01).

    Sources (3)
  8. Court order

    Civil contempt finding against prosecutor (gag order)

    Court or body
    Fourth District Court
    Case no.
    251403576
    Filed
    26 Jun 2026
    Brought by
    Defence (motion)
    Against
    Prosecutor Christopher Ballard

    Status (checked 26 Jun 2026) Held in civil contempt

    Contempt finding over public comments, including on ballistics.

    Bears on what officials may say in public.

    Sources (1)
    • Kirk Archive dataset
  9. Records appeal

    Schreifels (Salt Lake Tribune) v. Orem City

    Court or body
    Utah Government Records Office
    Case no.
    Decision 2026-002
    Filed
    2025
    Brought by
    Salt Lake Tribune reporter
    Against
    Orem City

    Status (checked 9 Mar 2026) Decided 9 Mar 2026 (see decision text)

    Records request to Orem City relating to the case.

    Access to municipal records.

    Sources (1)
  10. Records appeal

    Carlisle (FOX 13) v. Utah Valley University

    Court or body
    Utah Government Records Office
    Case no.
    Decision 2025-176
    Filed
    2025
    Brought by
    FOX 13 reporter
    Against
    Utah Valley University

    Status (checked 2 Mar 2026) Denied. Security plan is outside GRAMA ('security measures'); defence and County Attorney intervened.

    Request for UVU's event security plan.

    Why the security plan isn't public.

    Sources (2)
  11. Legislative

    Proposed campus event-security rules (2026 session)

    Court or body
    Utah Legislature
    Case no.
    see source
    Filed
    Jan 2026
    Brought by
    Utah lawmaker (sponsor)

    Status (checked 22 Jan 2026) Proposed; final status to confirm

    Sponsor says the rules might have prevented the shooting.

    Legislative response.

    Sources (1)
  12. Legislative

    US Senate Judiciary oversight hearing (FBI Director)

    Court or body
    US Senate
    Case no.
    n/a
    Filed
    16 Sep 2025
    Brought by
    Senate Judiciary Committee
    Against
    FBI Director Kash Patel (witness)

    Status (checked 16 Sep 2025) Held

    Testimony included the Kirk investigation and the Discord group chat.

    Federal oversight of agency statements (AG-01, AG-02).

    Sources (1)

Weigh the sources. Judge for yourself.

Spotted a source we missed, or a record that settles one of these questions? Send it in. Tips are anonymous and are checked before anything is published.

Share a source or correction How we source