Case compendium

Accounts matrix

For each topic, the official account first, then every other sourced account. Where they differ, the open question is stated plainly. The archive does not decide between them.

What the 53 questions add up to

Of 53 questions, 28 are settled by the record or by reliable outlets agreeing, 21 are disputed, and 4 rest on a single claim.

Every line links to its source. The archive does not say who is right. The defendant is presumed innocent.

Evening of 10 Sep: Panguitch restaurant sighting

ClaimedTimeline · key question

The official account

The court record has no Panguitch stop. Warrant affidavits place the defendant's Challenger at a car wash in Orem at 12:57, parked in an Orem neighbourhood near campus from about 00:23 to 01:20 on 11 Sep (neighbour's doorbell video), and starting a Google Maps route from near UVU to St. George at about 01:33. Texts quoted in the affidavits say he was 'stuck in orem'.

Sources (4)

Other accounts (1)

Owner of Cowboy's Smokehouse, Panguitch (unnamed, Fox News Digital, 17 Jan 2026) Claimed

A server was 'relatively certain' a lone diner at the counter that night was the defendant. The tip went to the FBI, who interviewed the owner and two servers. The card's last four digits went to the FBI, and the FBI has not confirmed a match.

Sources (1)

Open question Panguitch is about 3.5 hours by road (OSRM free-flow) from the Orem doorbell location (see geo legs). If he left about 21:47-22:00, could he be parked in Orem by 00:23? Did the FBI check the card digits?

Court documents (4)

Read the short question page →

Late-night return near campus, 11 Sep 00:23-01:20

Court recordLocations and movements · key question

The official account

A neighbour's Nest doorbell in an Orem neighbourhood near campus recorded a car matching the Challenger parked from about 00:23 to 01:20, with a person leaving and coming back (affidavit). The lead investigator testified that the fourth campus visit ran into the early hours of 11 Sep. Fox News reports officials saying he met an officer at the perimeter and was not seen as suspicious.

Sources (4)

Other accounts (1)

Panguitch restaurant staff Commentary · claim

Panguitch restaurant staff (see TL-07) claims (attributed, unverified): Places him about 3 hours' drive south until about 21:47-22:00 that night.

Sources (2)

Open question Is there any image of the driver during the 00:23-01:20 window, and does the timing fit the Panguitch claim?

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Bullet fragments and toolmark analysis

DisputedFirearm, gun photos, ballistics and bullet fragments · key question

The official account

The ATF examiner testified her toolmark comparison of the fatal fragment was inconclusive: it neither matched nor excluded the rifle. She received 4 of the 7 recovered fragments. The State plans to seek metallurgy and virtual comparison microscopy testing, and a hearing is set for 14 Jan 2027.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (1)

Defence filing (spring 2026) Reported

ATF could not identify the autopsy bullet to the rifle.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Open question Which four of the seven fragments were sent to ATF, and what further analysis is planned?

Read the short question page →

Who was responsible for rooftops and the perimeter

DisputedUVU campus security · key question

The official account

The after-action report: TPUSA security and UVUPD both failed to make sure a joint briefing and walk-through happened. No line-of-sight or rooftop plan existed. Barriers and cameras were added to the Losee roof afterwards.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (2)

Andrew Kolvet, TPUSA spokesperson (24 Sep 2025; 15 Dec 2025; 16 Sep 2026) Commentary · claim

Andrew Kolvet, TPUSA spokesperson (24 Sep 2025; 15 Dec 2025; 16 Sep 2026) claims (attributed, unverified): TPUSA's security had 'jurisdiction' only around Charlie. 'UVU Campus PD was in charge of perimeter.' The rooftop was a known student hangout.

Sources (3)

Executive-protection commentator (MSB Protection) Commentary · claim

Executive-protection commentator (MSB Protection) claims (attributed, unverified): Private security has no 'jurisdiction' anywhere. The duty is to advise the principal on risks.

Sources (1)

Open question What do records show about assignments to elevated positions and the planned 11:00 walkway meeting?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

NCTC access and 'foreign nexus' (Kent vs FBI)

DisputedAgency statements that changed or conflict · key question

The official account

FBI Assistant Director for Public Affairs Ben Williamson: NCTC is not an investigative agency and had 'ZERO role'. The FBI 'made an early exception and allowed NCTC to assess intelligence reports, and International Terrorism returned zero connections'.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (1)

Joe Kent, former NCTC Director (Megyn Kelly; Baron Coleman Ep 192) Commentary · claim

Joe Kent, former NCTC Director (Megyn Kelly; Baron Coleman Ep 192) claims (attributed, unverified): NCTC analysts were assisting the FBI-led Joint Terrorism Task Force, but after one to two weeks the FBI revoked access. He says leads, including a possible foreign nexus, weren't run down, and he may testify for the defence.

Sources (3)

Open question What did the NCTC assessment cover, and were any leads it raised passed to Utah prosecutors and the defence?

Read the short question page →

Arrival at the Washington County Sheriff's Office on 11 Sep (surrender)

DisputedTimeline · key question

The official account

SBI Investigator Justin Bowen's sworn warrant affidavits say the defendant 'arrived at the Washington County Sheriff's Office accompanied by his parents at approximately 2226 hours'.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (2)

Washington County Sheriff Nate Brooksby (public statements, via KUTV and Fox News) Reported

He got the tip call at about 8:02 p.m., and the defendant was brought in 'within the hour'. He then waited about 2½ hours for investigators from Orem.

Sources (2)

SBI case agent Brian Davis (prelim testimony, 8 Jul 2026; hearsay, 'I was told') Reported

Arrival around 21:00.

Sources (1)

Open question Did the defendant arrive at about 21:00 or at about 22:26? Two official accounts differ by roughly an hour and a half.

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Exit from the roof

DisputedLocations and movements · key question

The official account

Affidavits say the suspect sprinted north and dropped about 12-15 ft from the north-east corner, where prints and a smeared palm print were found. Officers said he dropped the rifle briefly, picked it up and ran north-east into a neighbourhood.

Sources (4)

Other accounts (1)

Fingerprint examiner (prelim testimony) Reported

Robinson was excluded as the source of the latent prints and the smeared palm print on that edge.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Open question Were the prints at the drop point compared with officers, staff and students, and what did those comparisons show?

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Dash camera in the Challenger

Court recordMotor vehicles · key question

The official account

On searching the car, investigators seized a Vantrue dash camera. Its power cord was disconnected and lying on the front passenger seat. Car-wash video suggested it had been mounted on the dash. It went to the Regional Computer Forensic Laboratory.

Sources (1)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What did the dash camera's card contain, and was anything deleted?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

The wound and the calibre

ClaimedFirearm, gun photos, ballistics and bullet fragments · key question

The official account

The medical examiner's autopsy report was admitted at the preliminary hearing without the examiner testifying and has not been released. Reporting says it found a gunshot wound to the neck, homicide, and recovered fragments.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (2)

John Mappin (businessman, X / interviews); Ian Carroll (X) Commentary · claim

John Mappin (businessman, X / interviews); Ian Carroll (X) claims (attributed, unverified): The visible wound with no apparent exit doesn't fit a .30-06.

Sources (2)

TriggerSmart (X) Claimed

An amateur ballistic-gel test of 5.56 vs .30-06 neck wounds.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Open question Will the medical examiner testify, and will the report describe the wound path and where the fragments were recovered?

Read the short question page →

DNA on the trigger

DisputedFirearm, gun photos, ballistics and bullet fragments · key question

The official account

The charging Information's probable-cause statement alleges DNA consistent with the defendant on the trigger, other rifle parts, a fired casing, unfired cartridges and the towel. The FBI's 15 Sep 2025 public announcement named the towel and the screwdriver.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (1)

Preliminary hearing testimony (FBI and SBI analysts) Disputed

Public testimony focused on a mixed DNA profile on the towel ('very likely' the defendant, plus the roommate). Trigger DNA was not described in reported testimony.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Open question Will the trigger DNA claimed in the charging document be backed by a lab report at trial?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

Police staffing at the event

DisputedUVU campus security · key question

The official account

Testimony and the after-action report: UVUPD fielded six sworn officers for about 3,000 people. Staffing began with the chief, one patrol officer and one reserve, and more were requested after the crowd grew. No Utah County deputies were there.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (2)

Security lead's own account (Shawn Ryan Show) Claimed

Kirk's personal detail was the security lead, the security supervisor, a driver and one more team member.

Sources (1)

Kirk family notice of claim (as reported) Disputed

Cites '25% of force'.

Sources (1)

Open question Was six officers in line with UVU's own major-event policy for an expected 600, then actual 3,000, attendance?

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Choice of the outdoor courtyard

DisputedUVU campus security · key question

The official account

The after-action report says UVU staff raised concerns at the 25 Aug Major Events Assessment Committee and suggested alternatives. TPUSA insisted on the Fountain Courtyard, citing Kirk's 2019 visit. The event was approved on 27 Aug before any security assessment.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Security lead Brian Harpole (own account, Shawn Ryan Show) Claimed

Attributed claim: He was concerned about the open-air venue and sightlines, but was told it 'needed to be held in that location'.

Sources (1)

Open question What do records show about the choice to keep the venue outdoors and the security lead's concerns?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

Pre-event coordination

DisputedUVU campus security · key question

The official account

The first direct UVUPD-TPUSA security contact was a 5 min 28 s call on 3 Sep. The chief's text proposing an 11:00 walkway meeting on 10 Sep did not lead to one. TPUSA's security supervisor, security lead, field representative, chapter president and national office did not take part in the review.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Kirk family notice of claim, as reported by Newsweek Disputed

Quotes the 8 Sep 16:11 text as 'I got you covered'. The after-action report has 'We got you covered'.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Open question Since the TPUSA side didn't take part in the review, its account of the coordination is untested. Will the civil claim bring out both sides' records?

Court documents (1)

Independent review's 'bad faith' finding vs the family's claim

DisputedUVU campus security · key question

The official account

The review found no UVU employee or agent acted in bad faith or with 'willful and wanton disregard'. It made 147 recommendations.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (1)

Kirk family (notice of claim, 16 Sep 2026) Disputed

Security failures by the State, UVU, UVUPD, the chief and the former president made the death preventable.

Sources (2)

Open question Utah's immunity law may turn on a 'willful and wanton' standard (see the Gabby Petito appeal). Will a court test the review's finding?

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Elevated positions that were covered

Official recordUVU campus security · key question

The official account

UVUPD cleared and taped off the Hall of Flags walkway above the canopy at TPUSA's security supervisor's request, and posted two officers there. The report found no documented review of other elevated positions, including the Losee Center roof.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Security lead Brian Harpole (own account) Claimed

'Federal law' would not allow his team to post a counter-sniper on a roof.

Sources (2)

Open question How did security assignments differ between the elevated walkway and the nearby Losee Center roof?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

Who chose the Fountain Courtyard (the review's own finding)

DisputedUVU campus security · key question

The official account

The after-action report: TPUSA's initial email of 10 Jul 2025 asked for the Fountain Courtyard. UVU raised concerns at the 25 Aug committee meeting but agreed when TPUSA's field representative insisted.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Security lead Brian Harpole (own account) Disputed

Attributed claim: The venue was chosen by UVU, which told TPUSA 'this is where you have to have it'.

Sources (2)

Open question What do the 10 July email and committee minutes say about the venue choice, if released?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

When the defendant first arrived on campus on 10 Sep

Court recordTimeline

The official account

A sworn warrant affidavit says UVU video shows the defendant's Challenger entering a campus parking structure on Campus Drive at ~800 West at 08:28, that he walked the campus (including near the wooded area where the rifle was later found and the event site) until 09:24, and drove out at 09:32 heading north-east. He is next seen walking back toward campus around 11:52-11:53. The lead investigator testified he was on campus about four times that day, twice before the shooting.

Sources (4)

Other accounts (2)

Gov. Spencer Cox (11 Sep press conference, via USA Today) Reported

Arrived about 8:29 a.m. in a grey Dodge Challenger.

Sources (1)

DPS Commissioner Beau Mason (11 Sep press conference) Reported

Surveillance tracked the suspect arriving on campus at 11:52 a.m.

Sources (1)

Open question Early official statements seemed to conflict (8:29 vs 11:52). The warrant record describes two separate visits. What was he doing during the morning visit, and where was he between 09:32 and 11:52?

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Hall of Flags walkway vs the Losee roof

Official recordLocations and movements

The official account

The after-action report says TPUSA security raised concerns on 8 and 10 Sep about the elevated Hall of Flags walkway above the stage. UVU police cleared 80-100 protesters from it and taped it off that morning. The shot came from a different structure, the Losee Center roof.

Sources (1)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question The after-action report describes officers on the walkway and no assignment to the nearby Losee roof. What does the report say about those positions?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

Car wash in Orem, 12:57 on 10 Sep

Court recordLocations and movements

The official account

SBI got Quick Quack Car Wash (855 N State St, Orem) records and video showing the Challenger arriving at about 12:57, 34 minutes after the shot. A Google Maps route on his phone started at 12:46 MDT from near a shopping complex about seven minutes from campus to that car wash.

Sources (2)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What do the available reports and warrant documents say about the car-wash stop and when it became public?

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Phone use on campus before the shot

Court recordPhones and phone usage

The official account

Affidavits describe the suspect pausing at the top of the tunnel stairs at about 11:53 and taking what looks like a phone from his right pocket. They cite UVU video of the shooter 'utilizing his cellphone near the time and in the vicinity of the shooting'.

Sources (2)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question Has the phone's location history for 11:35-12:40 been matched to this footage? The geofence and tower-dump results are not public.

Court documents (2)

Geofence and tower-dump windows, including 8 Sep 20:10-20:25

Court recordPhones and phone usage

The official account

Warrants sought Google location data for 10 Sep 11:35-12:40 around the Losee Center and campus, and cell-tower dumps for 10 Sep windows. One also covered 8 Sep 20:10-20:25 for an area in Orem.

Sources (2)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What happened at that place on the evening of 8 Sep that made investigators ask for that window? The affidavit excerpts reviewed don't explain it, and none of the results are public.

Court documents (2)

Licence plate as written in court records

DisputedMotor vehicles

The official account

Warrant 3213501 gives the Challenger's Utah plate as a 5-character form beginning 'T44**'. Warrants 3215391 and 3216271 give a 6-character form beginning 'T455**', including for the Cedar City licence-plate-reader hit.

Sources (3)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question Which plate is right? A licence-plate-reader match depends on the exact plate.

Court documents (3)

Read the short question page →

Empty holster near the scene

ClaimedFirearm, gun photos, ballistics and bullet fragments

The official account

Officer Bagley testified he found an empty handgun holster while securing the scene. Its owner is unclear. Reporting from cross-examination says it was not collected. Separately, the parents' home warrant sought a Smith & Wesson M&P pistol and holster.

Sources (2)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What is known about the empty holster near the scene, whether it was collected and whether it relates to the pistol named in the home warrant?

Court documents (1)

Clothing across the day

DisputedCCTV, Ring and photographs

The official account

Affidavits give three looks. On the morning visit: ball cap, red T-shirt, light shorts, Converse-style shoes. At the shooting: blue hat, sunglasses, long-sleeve black shirt with a flag-and-eagle print, dark jeans, white/grey Converse-style shoes. At surrender: dark hat, maroon T-shirt, jeans, white/grey Converse-style shoes ('not consistent' with the UVU footage).

Sources (3)

Other accounts (1)

Fox News, citing charging documents Disputed

Morning: light shorts, a black hat with a white logo.

Sources (1)

Open question Was the black flag-and-eagle shirt ever recovered? Is the morning hat blue, black or something else?

Court documents (3)

Real-time camera monitoring at the event

Official recordCCTV, Ring and photographs

The official account

The after-action report finds cameras were more useful after the incident than in real time, and that no one was assigned to watch relevant feeds live.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Andrew Kolvet (Fox News) Commentary · claim

Andrew Kolvet (Fox News) claims (attributed, unverified): 'They weren't watching CCTV at the same time.'

Sources (1)

Open question Could live monitoring have spotted the rooftop approach between 12:15 and 12:22?

Court documents (1)

Projected vs actual attendance and ticketing

Official recordUVU campus security

The official account

TPUSA projected about 600 and reported no risk factors. About 3,000 attended. Ticketing was TPUSA-managed and totals were never shared, so the UVU chief could not estimate the crowd. There was no screening and no metal detectors.

Sources (1)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What records describe the availability of ticket totals before the event?

Court documents (1)

Campus alerts after the shot

Official recordUVU campus security

The official account

The first campus-wide alert, at 12:42, said a suspect was in custody. That was wrong and was corrected about 20 minutes later. Later alerts were inconsistent, and one was retracted within two minutes.

Sources (1)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What source did officials cite for the 12:42 'suspect in custody' alert?

Court documents (1)

'Subject in custody' (10 Sep)

Official recordAgency statements that changed or conflict

The official account

FBI Director Kash Patel posted at 16:21 MDT that 'the subject ... is now in custody', then at 17:59 MDT that the person 'has been released after an interrogation'. He later said he didn't regret the posts.

Sources (3)

Other accounts (1)

Utah officials (same evening, via CBS) Reported

The shooter was still at large.

Sources (1)

Open question What is known about the person released, and whether the 12:42 UVU alert and FBI post relied on the same information?

Read the short question page →

Security plan withheld from the public

Official recordAfter-the-event developments

The official account

The Government Records Office ruled UVU's event security plan is outside GRAMA under the 'security measures' exclusion. The defence and the County Attorney intervened against release.

Sources (2)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question Will the security plan come out in the civil claim or at trial?

Court documents (1)

Prosecutor held in contempt over public comments

ReportedAfter-the-event developments

The official account

On 26 Jun 2026, Judge Graf held prosecutor Christopher Ballard in civil contempt for gag-order violations, including spring 2026 ballistics comments and a TMZ 'ample evidence' remark.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What did the prosecutor say publicly about the ballistics that the court found improper?

Read the short question page →

The man who falsely claimed to be the shooter

Court recordAfter-the-event developments

The official account

According to charging documents, George Zinn, 71, told a UVU police detective 'I shot him, now shoot me' about two minutes after the shot; he was handcuffed about 12:25 pm, no gun was found, and he was taken to the UVU Police Department. Investigators later said he did not shoot Kirk; the sheriff's office said it had no information that he colluded with the shooter. He was charged with obstruction of justice. On 29 Jan 2026 he pleaded no contest to a reduced third-degree obstruction charge and was sentenced to 0-5 years, concurrent with sentences in a separate case that arose from the search of his phone. The parole board sets the time served.

Sources (9)

Other accounts (2)

Police booking affidavit (as reported by KSL, the Salt Lake Tribune and The Guardian) Reported

At the hospital later that day, Zinn told an officer he 'was glad he said he shot the individual so the real suspect could get away'. The sheriff's office said it had no information that he colluded with the shooter.

Sources (4)

Texts attributed to the defendant (affidavit) Reported

'they grabbed some crazy old dude, then interrogated someone in similar clothing'.

Sources (1)

Open question How many officers did the false confession tie up, and for how long, in the minutes the shooter was leaving the roof?

Court documents (3)

Read the short question page →

Drones and Provo Airport airspace

DisputedUVU campus security

The official account

The after-action report says drone operations are restricted within five miles of Provo Airport (Class D). UVU is at least six miles from the airport. A drone could have been requested from the neighbouring Orem Police Department.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Security lead Brian Harpole (own account, Shawn Ryan Show, as summarised in the after-action report) Disputed

Attributed claim: His team had drones but did not fly them during the event because of FAA restrictions tied to Provo Airport airspace. TPUSA's video team flew a 'little-bitty' drone for a venue shot beforehand.

Sources (2)

Open question Did airspace rules actually prevent an overhead drone at UVU that day, and was a police drone ever requested?

Court documents (1)

False-suspect custody report and the first campus alert

Official recordTimeline

The official account

After-action report timeline: 12:26 UVUPD reports a suspect (an attendee) in custody after he allegedly admitted involvement; later determined not a suspect. The first campus alert at 12:42 said a suspect was in custody, corrected about 20 minutes later.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Press reporting Reported

The man who shouted 'I shot him' was detained by a UVU detective and walked to UVU PD about two minutes after the shot.

Sources (2)

Open question How long did the false-suspect report shape the first campus alerts and outside agency messaging?

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Time of the shot

DisputedTimeline

The official account

Charging documents, the geofence warrant affidavit and the after-action report put the single shot at about 12:23 p.m. MDT on 10 Sep 2025.

Sources (3)

Other accounts (2)

UVU (initial public statement, via USA Today) Disputed

An initial university figure of about 12:10 p.m.

Sources (1)

Utah DPS (initial release, via USA Today) Disputed

About 12:20 p.m. (reportedly labelled MST).

Sources (1)

Open question How do the early official times compare with the charging documents, and has any agency corrected its early figure?

Sourced note Early Utah DPS press releases gave the time as “approximately 12:20 pm” (Updates on Charlie Kirk shooting at UVU (DPS press…, Media advisory). The charging documents, the probable-cause statement and the university review give about 12:23. The archive treats this as rounding in early releases, not a contradiction.

Court documents (3)

Read the short question page →

Return to St. George on 11 Sep

ClaimedTimeline

The official account

No arrival time is in the public record.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Diligent Denizen Commentary · claim

Diligent Denizen claims (attributed, unverified): The car returned between 07:36 and 08:36.

Sources (1)

Open question The two presenters of the same footage give different arrival windows. Which is right, and is the camera clock accurate?

Court documents (8)

Read the short question page →

Firing position

Court recordLocations and movements

The official account

Charging documents, the warrant affidavits and officer testimony place the shooter prone on the Losee Center roof. A screwdriver and a disturbed gravel 'sniper's pad' were found, plus shoe, forearm and palm impressions.

Sources (3)

Other accounts (1)

Online commentators (alternative-narrative communities) Commentary · claim

Online commentators (alternative-narrative communities) claims (attributed, unverified): A second shooter or another firing position.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Open question What does the available rooftop camera footage show, and has the complete recording been made public?

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Discord

Court recordPhones and phone usage

The official account

The FBI Director told the Senate Judiciary Committee the FBI was investigating a Discord group chat. Warrants sought Discord data for 27 Aug-12 Sep 2025 (September) and again in October.

Sources (3)

Other accounts (2)

Discord (company spokesperson) Reported

Its internal investigation found 'no evidence that the suspect planned this incident or promoted violence on Discord'. It confirmed messages including 'It was me at UVU yesterday'.

Sources (2)

Andrew Kolvet (TPUSA, X) Party statement

Friends on Discord said the FBI images looked like him, and he called it his 'doppelgänger'.

Sources (1)

Open question What prompted the second Discord warrant in October, and what did it cover?

Court documents (2)

The rifle

Court recordFirearm, gun photos, ballistics and bullet fragments

The official account

A Mauser Model 98 .30-06 bolt-action rifle with a scope, wrapped in a dark towel, with engraved casings. Texts quoted in affidavits call it 'grandpa's rifle'.

Sources (3)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question Has the chain of custody from the wooded area to the lab been fully documented in discovery?

Court documents (3)

Read the short question page →

Edited surveillance compilation

ReportedCCTV, Ring and photographs

The official account

Prosecutors admitted that parts of their campus-video compilation had been enhanced with circles. Judge Graf required an unedited version. The defence objected to all footage as hearsay.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Andrew Kolvet (TPUSA, X) Party statement

Posted the compilation (exhibit 12.4) showing four campus visits.

Sources (1)

Open question Will the full unedited campus footage, timestamps included, be made public?

Read the short question page →

Body-camera footage withheld

Official recordCCTV, Ring and photographs

The official account

Utah's Government Records Office upheld Orem City withholding 50+ body-camera videos (about 10 hours reviewed in camera) as protected evidence, at the request of the Utah County Attorney's Office and SBI.

Sources (1)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question The decision invites a fresh request after the trial ends. Which parts will become public, and when?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

Threat reporting on the morning of the event

Official recordUVU campus security

The official account

An anonymous threat reported to the state intelligence centre (SIAC) at 07:23 on 10 Sep was found to be unsubstantiated.

Sources (1)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What did the threat say, and was it passed to TPUSA's security team?

Court documents (1)

How the surrender was arranged

DisputedAgency statements that changed or conflict

The official account

Affidavit: Utah County Sheriff Smith got a call at about 20:04 from Washington County Sheriff Brooksby, who had heard from a former sheriff's deputy who knew the family. The defendant had confessed to his father. Brooksby (KUTV): a 'retired detective' friend called him at about 8:02 p.m.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (1)

CBS News, citing law-enforcement sources Disputed

His father called a youth pastor, a court security officer, who also called the US Marshals Service.

Sources (1)

Open question Was the intermediary one person or two, and did the US Marshals have a role before the sheriff's office?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

Size of discovery

DisputedAfter-the-event developments

The official account

The court's 9 Nov 2026 order recites 49 productions, 30,983 files, ~3.3 TB, plus ~8 million digital artefacts, some on inaccessible or corrupted devices.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Other accounts (1)

Defence status report (Aug 2026, via KSL) Disputed

About 12.1 TB across 613,023 files, including six mobile devices and fourteen hard-drive images.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Open question Are the figures counting different things? Which devices are 'inaccessible or corrupted'?

Read the short question page →

Victim transport to hospital

Official recordTimeline

The official account

After-action report: about 12:35, Orem fire personnel passed the TPUSA security SUV taking Charlie Kirk to Timpanogos Regional Hospital. Fire Station Two rerouted to the hospital. The first Orem Fire and Police units arrived at UVU at 12:32.

Sources (1)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What does the record say about transport to the hospital and arrival time?

Court documents (1)

Date of the surrender

DisputedTimeline

The official account

Court records, the FBI and wire reporting put the surrender and custody on the evening of 11 Sep 2025, with booking on 12 Sep.

Sources (3)

Other accounts (1)

UVU after-action report Disputed

Dates the surrender to 12 Sep 2025.

Sources (1)

Open question How does the university's official review date compare with the court record?

Court documents (3)

Read the short question page →

Booking / arrest time on 12 Sep

DisputedTimeline

The official account

The booking probable-cause statement records the arrest as 12 Sep 2025 04:00 and 'Probable Cause Entered 07:18'. The sheriff said he was driven to Utah County at about 02:00.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (1)

ABC4 reporting Disputed

Booking at 8:40 a.m.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Open question What do the records say about the reported booking time and what each timestamp records?

Court documents (1)

Read the short question page →

When Charlie Kirk's death was confirmed

Official recordTimeline

The official account

The after-action report records the UVU police chief telling the Emergency Operations Center at 13:41 that Kirk had died. The public announcement came at about 14:40 MDT. No pronouncement time is in the public sources reviewed.

Sources (1)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question What time was death formally pronounced, and by whom? The autopsy report was submitted at the preliminary hearing but has not been released.

Court documents (1)

Phone-record warrant date range

Court recordPhones and phone usage

The official account

Two phone-records warrants for the same number request data from 27 Aug 2024 to 12 Sep 2025. A sibling warrant for another number uses 27 Aug 2025. Phone numbers are withheld here.

Sources (2)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question Is the 2024 start date a typo or a deliberate one-year look-back?

Court documents (2)

Make of the vehicle

DisputedMotor vehicles

The official account

The probable-cause statement and affidavits say a grey 2013 Dodge Challenger, co-owned by the defendant.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (1)

Judge's bind-over ruling as read aloud (third-party Rev transcript, 1 Sep 2026) Disputed

'gray or silver Dodge Charger' at 8:30.

Sources (1)

Open question Is 'Charger' a misspeak or a transcription error? Check against the signed ruling.

Court documents (3)

Read the short question page →

Rooftop timing: report vs affidavits

Court recordCCTV, Ring and photographs

The official account

Affidavits: walking up the stairs to the common area at 12:15, running across the roof at 12:22, standing and sprinting north at 12:23.

Sources (2)

Other accounts (1)

UVU after-action report Reported

Footage shows the assailant accessing the roof at 12:17 and going prone at 12:22.

Sources (1)

Open question These are close and broadly consistent. Has anyone published the camera clock offsets?

Court documents (3)

Number of charges

Court recordAfter-the-event developments

The official account

Seven counts (Information; bind-over on all seven).

Sources (2)

Other accounts (1)

KSL (6 Jul 2026 article) Disputed

'He faces 10 charges'. KSL corrected this on 10 Jul 2026.

Sources (1)

Open question Resolved: seven counts plus enhancement paragraphs.

Court documents (2)

Read the short question page →

Date the roommate's recorded interview was played

DisputedAfter-the-event developments

The official account

Testimony confirms the recorded April 2026 interview was played instead of live testimony, and that he had use immunity.

Sources (1)

Other accounts (1)

Reporting (various) Disputed

Dated 7, 8 or 9 Jul 2026 depending on the outlet.

Sources (1)
  • Kirk Archive dataset

Open question Which day was it played? Check the minute entries.

UVU leadership and safety changes

ReportedAfter-the-event developments

The official account

After the review, UVU filled a new top campus-safety post (Utah News Dispatch, Oct 2026). Barriers and cameras now cover the Losee roof. UVU raised police pay and moved to add officers.

Sources (3)

Other accounts

No other account recorded.

Open question Has UVU said which of the 147 recommendations it has adopted?

Where the records conflict (6)

Where the records conflict

Places where two sourced accounts appear not to line up. They are open questions, not findings. Many probably have ordinary explanations, such as different steps in the process, rounding, camera clocks or typing errors.

In the contradiction graph

Reviewed and added to the contradiction graph as an open question. Neither account is treated as wrong.

Arrival at the Washington County Sheriff's Office on 11 Sep (surrender)

In the contradiction graph

Formal account

SBI Investigator Justin Bowen's sworn warrant affidavits say the defendant 'arrived at the Washington County Sheriff's Office accompanied by his parents at approximately 2226 hours'.

Sources (1)

Source links open in a new tab.

Washington County Sheriff Nate Brooksby (public statements, via KUTV and Fox News)

He got the tip call at about 8:02 p.m., and the defendant was brought in 'within the hour'. He then waited about 2½ hours for investigators from Orem.

Sources (1)

Source links open in a new tab.

Open question Two official accounts differ by about 1.5 hours. The archive does not say which is right. The evidence at trial may settle it.

See it in the contradiction graph

Topic: Arrival at the Washington County Sheriff's Office on 11 Sep (surrender)

Open questions

Reviewed and shown as open questions. They are not in the contradiction graph.

Date of the surrender

Open question

Formal account

Court records, the FBI and wire reporting put the surrender and custody on the evening of 11 Sep 2025, with booking on 12 Sep.

Sources (1)

Source links open in a new tab.

UVU after-action report

Dates the surrender to 12 Sep 2025.

Sources (1)

Source links open in a new tab.

Open question The university's official review and the court record give different dates for the surrender.

Topic: Date of the surrender

Custody, surrender and arrest times on 11–12 Sep

Open question

The charging Information says he surrendered on the evening of 11 Sep. The FBI Director said he was taken into custody at 10 p.m. local time, and repeated it to the House Judiciary Committee. The booking probable-cause statement gives the arrest as 12 Sep at 04:00. Other warrants record a call to the Utah County Sheriff at about 20:04 and an FBI interview of the roommate at about 01:00.

Open question Do these describe different steps (surrender, custody, formal arrest, booking) or different accounts of the same moment?

Documents: Information (criminal charges), Affidavit of Probable Cause (booking), Director Patel's remarks at the 12 Sep 2025 press…, Hearing record, Search warrant No. 3214311 and affidavit, Search warrant No. 3229461 and affidavit · Topic: Arrival at the Washington County Sheriff's Office on 11 Sep (surrender)

When the Challenger was parked near campus overnight

Open question

Three vehicle warrants say the car parked at 'approximately 1247 hours on September 11, 1025 [sic]' and left at 01:35. Another warrant says the same doorbell footage shows it parking at about 00:23 and leaving at about 01:20. Phone map data in a further warrant shows a route starting at about 01:33.

Open question Which window is right? '1247 hours' may be meant as 00:47. The original footage times are not public.

Documents: Search warrant No. 3213501 and affidavit, Search warrant No. 3214771 and affidavit, Search warrant No. 3215391 and affidavit, Search warrant No. 3213811 and affidavit, Search warrant No. 3215261 and affidavit · Topic: Late-night return near campus, 11 Sep 00:23-01:20

Video release and the family's first call

Open question

The FBI's updates page lists the shooter video at 10 p.m. Eastern (8 p.m. in Utah) on 11 Sep, and four more photos at 9:05 p.m. Eastern. The FBI Director told Congress the family recognised their son from the video. A warrant records a relayed call to the Utah County Sheriff at about 20:04 Utah time, after the family had already contacted a former deputy.

Open question Was the recognition tied to the 8 p.m. video or to the earlier photos?

Documents: Utah Valley Shooting Updates (FBI running page,…, Director Patel's opening statement to the Senate…, Hearing record, Search warrant No. 3229461 and affidavit · Topic: Arrival at the Washington County Sheriff's Office on 11 Sep (surrender)

Candidate for review

Still being checked. Not in the contradiction graph. Plates are shown partly masked.

Licence plate as written in court records

For review

Formal account

Warrant 3213501 gives the Challenger's Utah plate as a 5-character form beginning 'T44**'. Warrants 3215391 and 3216271 give a 6-character form beginning 'T455**', including for the Cedar City licence-plate-reader hit.

Sources (1)

Source links open in a new tab.

Other warrants

Warrants 3215391 and 3216271 give a 6-character form beginning 'T455**', including for the Cedar City licence-plate-reader hit.

Sources (1)

Source links open in a new tab.

Open question Two forms of the same plate appear in the warrants (shown here partly masked). It may be a typing error. It matters because a licence-plate-reader match depends on the exact plate. The court-documents review logged the same issue as DC-3, merged here.

Documents: Search warrant No. 3213501 and affidavit, Search warrant No. 3215391 and affidavit · Topic: Licence plate as written in court records

7 other candidates were reviewed by the editor on 14 Nov 2026 and set aside.

Weigh the sources. Judge for yourself.

Spotted a source we missed, or a record that settles one of these questions? Send it in. Tips are anonymous and are checked before anything is published.

Share a source or correction How we source